P&M Fine Foods New Haven

721 Orange St, New Haven, CT

Most ordered

SKIP THE LINE & ORDER AHEAD FOR 8/26! 🍕

Available for preorder all week! * Schedule Your Pickup: Choose a specific time between 5–8 PM when you place your order, and we’ll have your pizza ready when you arrive. * Just Stopping By? No problem! Bring your order receipt with you, and we’ll prioritize your pizza and make it fresh for you. It should only take a few minutes! Skip the wait, secure your pizza, and enjoy it fresh! ❤️

Margherita

$17.00

Our classic take on a favorite, with house-made tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, EVOO, and basil

Mozzarella

$17.00

The classic MOOTSZ, fresh tomato sauce, shredded mozzarella, and topped with grated pecorino romano

Pepperoni

$18.00

house-made tomato sauce, melted mozzarella, and plenty of savory, crispy-edged pepperoni

Mario & Maria

$21.00

House-made tomato sauce, topped with eggplant, mushrooms, garlic, ricotta, and fresh basil

Vegan Rockstar

$20.00

Red base, topped with spinach, grilled onion, and tomato slices

Ricotta Rosso

$21.00

White base, topped with native tomatoes, basil, garlic, and dollops of ricotta, dressed with EVOO

Breakfast

Bagel & Cream Cheese

$3.50

Egg & Cheese Sandwich

$3.50

With one egg

Egg & Cheese Bagel

$5.00

With one egg

Egg & Cheese Sub

$7.50+

With three eggs

Avocado Glazed Toast

$7.99

Avocado, sun dried tomato pesto (nut free) basil & balsamic glaze

Down & Dirty Wrap

$8.95+

Two eggs with your choice of bacon, sausage or ham & your choice of cheese

The Flag Wrap

$8.95+

Two eggs, fresh mozz cheese, tomato, basil, EVOO, salt & pepper

Healthy Choice Wrap

$8.95+

Grilled veggies, egg whites & Swiss cheese

Mexican Wrap

$8.95+

Two eggs, mozz cheese & salsa

Salad & Bowls

Baby Spinach Salad

$17.50+

Baby spinach, cranberries, pecans, apple, red onions, carrot, avocado, & P&M's house dressing

Caesar Salad

$12.50+

Romaine, croutons, grated cheese, & Caesar dressing

Cobb Salad

$18.89+

Grilled chicken, bacon, tomato, hard boiled egg, avocado, onion, crumbled blue cheese, & ranch dressing

Greek Salad

$11.99+

Mesclun greens, cucumbers, bell peppers, tomato, red onion, kalamata olives, feta cheese, & golden Italian dressing

Grilled Ahi Tuna Salad

$14.00+

Mixed greens, ahi tuna, tomato, red onions, cucumbers, bell pepper. & P&M's house dressing

Insalata Fresca Salad

$16.79+

Mesclun, strawberries, apples, dried cranberries, almonds, grilled chicken, & raspberry vinaigrette

Italian Chop Salad

$17.89+

Genoa Salami, Chick Peas, red onion, Artichokes, Pitted Castel Vetrano Olives, celery, Provolone, Parsley, Hearts of Palm Paired w/ seasoned EVOO & Red wine vinegar

Mediterranean Hummus Bowl

$13.50

Brown rice, diced cucumbers, red onion, cherry tomatoes, pitted kalamata olives, crumbled feta, topped with hummus. Dressed with squeezed fresh lemon, EVOO, oregano, salt & pepper, topped with parsley.

Southwest Crunch Bowl

$13.95

Quinoa, black beans, roasted corn, grilled chicken, roasted chickpeas, red onion, arugula, sweet potato & tortilla strips. Dressed with light ranch and balsamic glaze

Cold Specials Sub

Add lettuce, tomato & choice of condiment

Ham & Cheese Cold Sub

$14.50

Boar’s Head deluxe ham

Turkey & Cheese Cold Sub

$15.00

Boar's Head Ovengold turkey

Roast Beef & Cheese Cold Sub

$17.50

Store-made top round roast

Tuna or Chicken Salad Cold Sub

$16.50

American Combo Cold Sub

$16.50

Roast beef, turkey, ham & American cheese

Italian Combo Cold Sub

$16.50

Ham, salami, provolone, capicola & pepperoni

Italian Flag Cold Sub

$13.50

With Liuzzi mozzarella, tomato basil, EVOO, salt & pepper

Mortadella Cold Sub

$16.50

With Liuzzi mozz, tomato, basil, EVOO, salt & pepper, pistachios

Prosciutto Cold Sub

$17.50

With Liuzzi mozzarella, tomato basil, EVOO, salt & pepper

Cold Specials Roll

Add lettuce, tomato & choice of condiment

Ham & Cheese Cold Roll

$9.85

Boar’s Head deluxe ham

Turkey & Cheese Cold Roll

$9.85

Boar's Head Ovengold turkey

Roast Beef & Cheese Cold Roll

$10.50

Store-made top round roast

Tuna or Chicken Salad Cold Roll

$10.50

American Combo Cold Roll

$9.85

Roast beef, turkey, ham & American cheese

Italian Combo Cold Roll

$9.85

Ham, salami, provolone, capicola & pepperoni

Italian Flag Cold Roll

$9.85

With Liuzzi mozzarella, tomato basil, EVOO, salt & pepper

Mortadella Cold Roll

$9.85

With Liuzzi mozz, tomato, basil, EVOO, salt & pepper, pistachios

Prosciutto Cold Roll

$10.50

With Liuzzi mozzarella, tomato, basil, EVOO, salt & pepper

Hot Specials Sub

Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Hot Sub

$15.50

Sauteed rabe with garlic & sweet Italian sausage

Chicken Brunello Hot Sub

$14.45

Chicken cutlet with roasted peppers & provolone

Chicken Cacciatore Hot Sub

$15.50

Simmered in tomato stock with mushrooms

Chicken Gaggiana Hot Sub

$15.50

Gorgonzola spicy sauce with light cream & roasted peppers

Chicken Parmigiana Hot Sub

$16.50

Chicken cutlet, P&M's marinara sauce & mozz

Chicken Sandrella Hot Sub

$16.50

Chicken cutlet with broccoli rabe and provolone

Chicken Santore Hot Sub

$17.50

Chicken cutlet, pepperoni, roasted red peppers, provolone & honey mustard

The Classic Hot Sub

$16.50

Eggplant Parm topped with chicken cutlet & melted mozz

Club Hot Sub

$17.50

Bacon, American cheese, lettuce & tomato. Add turkey, grilled chicken, or chicken cutlet

Eggplant Parmigiana Hot Sub

$15.50

Fried eggplant with P&M's marinara & grated cheese

Meatballs Hot Sub

$15.50

Fresh homemade meatballs made with P&M's marinara & grated cheese

Pino's Favorite Hot Sub

$17.50

Prosciutto, tomato, basil, salt, pepper, EVOO, topped with Liuzzi's fresh ricotta

Sausage & Peppers Hot Sub

$15.50

Sweet Italian sausage & bell peppers

Tuna or Chicken Salad Melt Hot Sub

$17.50

With melted provolone

Chicken Cutlet Hot Sub

$16.00

Grilled Chicken Hot Sub

$16.00

Hot Specials Roll

Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Hot Roll

$9.85

Sautéed broccoli rabe with garlic & sweet Italian sausage

Chicken Brunello Hot Roll

$9.85

Chicken cutlet with roasted peppers & provolone

Chicken Cacciatore Hot Roll

$9.85

Simmered in tomato stock with mushrooms

Chicken Gaggiana Hot Roll

$9.85

Gorgonzola spicy sauce with light cream & roasted peppers

Chicken Parmigiana Hot Roll

$10.50

Chicken cutlet, P&M's marinara sauce & mozz

Chicken Sandrella Hot Roll

$10.50

Chicken cutlet with broccoli rabe

Chicken Santore Hot Roll

$10.99

Chicken cutlet, pepperoni, roasted red peppers, provolone & honey mustard

The Classic Hot Roll

$10.99

Eggplant Parm topped with chicken cutlet & melted mozz

Club Hot Roll

$10.99

Bacon, American cheese, lettuce & tomato. Add turkey, grilled chicken, or chicken cutlet

Eggplant Parmigiana Hot Roll

$9.85

Fried eggplant with P&M's marinara & grated cheese

Meatballs Hot Roll

$9.49

Fresh homemade meatballs made with P&M's marinara & grated cheese

Pino's Favorite Hot Roll

$10.50

Prosciutto, tomato, basil, salt, pepper, EVOO, topped with Liuzzi's fresh ricotta

Sausage & Peppers Hot Roll

$9.85

Sweet Italian sausage & bell peppers

Tuna or Chicken Salad Melt Hot Roll

$10.50

With melted provolone

Chicken Cutlet Hot Roll

$10.50

Grilled Chicken Hot Roll

$10.50

Panini on Focaccia

The Brunello Panini

$14.45

Chicken cutlet, roasted red peppers & melted provolone

BBQ Chicken Ranch Panini

$15.75

Chicken cutlet, avocado, bacon, Cheddar & ranch

Chicken Pesto Panini

$14.45

Sun-dried tomato pesto (nut free), mesclun & grilled chicken

East Rocker Panini (Local Favorite)

$15.75

Sun-dried tomato pesto (nut free), goat cheese, red onions, mixed greens & grilled chicken

The Flag Panini (Classic Favorite)

$11.95

Fresh mozzarella, tomato, basil, topped with salt, pepper & EVOO

Honey Mustard Chicken Panini

$13.95

Fresh mozz, grilled chicken, & honey mustard

Italiano Panini

$15.75

Parma prosciutto, sweet soppressata, sharp provolone, tomato, roasted red pepper, basil & EVOO

Latino Panini

$15.75

Grilled chicken, fresh bistro ham, pickles, Swiss cheese, mayo, sun-dried tomato pesto (nut free)

Manfro Panini (Classic Favorite)

$15.75

Grilled chicken, red peppers, balsamic vinegar, prosciutto & fresh mozz

Portobello Panini

$13.95

Grilled portobello mushroom, red roasted pepper Gorgonzola, & mesclun

The Veggie Panini

$12.75

Fresh grilled veggies, EVOO, balsamic vinegar & fresh mozz

Vesuvio Panini

$14.75

Smoked turkey, broccoli rabe, Cheddar cheese & kalamata olives

Wraps

Black Russian Wrap

$16.50

Roast beef, coleslaw, Swiss & thousand island dressing

Buffalo Chicken Wrap

$14.50

Chicken cutlet, with buffalo sauce, american cheese, lettuce & blue cheese

Casanova Wrap

$14.50

Vegan. Hummus, artichoke heart, tomato, basil, red onion, broccoli rabe, roasted peppers, grilled eggplant, balsamic glaze

Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap

$13.50

Grilled chicken, romaine, croutons, grated cheese & Caesar dressing

The Greek Wrap

$14.50

Grilled chicken, with lettuce, tomato, feta, kalamata olives & tzatziki sauce

Mediterranean Wrap

$15.50

Turkey, avocado, artichoke hearts, basil, red onions & P&M's house dressing

The Roast Beef Wrap

$16.50

Homemade roast beef with Swiss or Muenster, lettuce, tomato, salt, pepper & horseradish sauce

White Russian Wrap

$13.50

Turkey, coleslaw, Swiss & thousand island dressing

Smokin' Good-Ah Chicken Wrap

$13.50

Grilled chicken, smoked Gouda, hummus, roasted red peppers, red onion & mesclun greens

Off the Grill Subs

Jimmy Burger Sub

$14.50

Fresh in-house made ground beef, hand pressed & cooked to perfection, lettuce, tomato, red onion, mayo, ketchup, & choice of cheese on two 8 oz patties

Pastrami Melt Sub

$15.95

Pastrami, lettuce, tomato, deli mustard & Swiss cheese