Welcome to P&M Fine Foods - New Haven Location
Nestled along historic Orange Street, our New Haven spot blends urban charm with neighborhood friendliness. Just steps away from the cultural pulse of downtown, this location captures the spirit of the city — lively, diverse, and full of flavor. Whether you’re on the go or dining in, it’s a slice of local life you’ll love.
Visit Us Now
Stop by today and taste why locals call us the heart of Connecticut flavor!
Location: 721 Orange St, New Haven, CT 06511
Operating Hours:
Monday–Saturday: 7:00 AM – 8:00 PM
Sunday: 7:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Crafted with Care: Our Food Philosophy
At P&M Fine Foods, food isn’t just served — it’s crafted. Every dish begins with fresh, high-quality ingredients, from locally sourced produce to hand-sliced deli meats and artisan cheeses. Our menu is a celebration of Italian-American flavors: hot paninis, pasta plates, crisp salads, and famous stuffed breads baked to perfection. Every bite is a taste of tradition, done the P&M way.
Order Now & Satisfy Your Cravings
Skip the wait and enjoy your favorites fast! Order online or call ahead for quick pickup. Whether you’re craving a classic Italian combo, a fresh salad, or a hot meal to go, we make ordering easy, fast, and delicious — perfect for lunch breaks, family dinners, or weekend treats.
A Feast For The Eyes
Catch a glimpse of our kitchen’s heart and soul.
Catering Made Easy
Hosting a party, office lunch, or family celebration? Let P&M Fine Foods handle the food! Choose from trays of our famous sandwiches, pasta dishes, and signature deli platters. Whether it’s a small gathering or a large event, from an office lunch for 20 to a wedding for 200, we’ll make it simple and delicious.
Don't Miss Our Sweet Delights
The P&M Experience
Step inside and feel the warmth of a true neighborhood deli. Friendly faces, fresh aromas, and the hum of great conversation fill the air. Whether you’re stopping in for your morning espresso or grabbing lunch with friends, P&M Fine Foods offers a welcoming, energetic atmosphere where every visit feels like coming home.
What our guests are saying
Extremely nice staff - great local place.
Bill V.
They have all sorts of sandwiches. Wanted to check this place out after watching Joel Hansen take on a food challenge there. The hot sandwiches are really great! The atmosphere and outdoor seating felt super homey.
Maddie H.
This P&M is superior. Their food is always hot and fresh. A1 customer service
Mani P.
Featuring
Catering
Delivery
Take Out
Dine In
P&M Fine Foods Rewards
Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online, and redeem your points for free food!
Frequently Asked Questions
What are you known for?
We are known for Sausage, Eggs, Spinach Salad, Margherita Pizza, Gnocchi, Bagels, Veggie Pizza, Wings, Breakfast Wrap, Penne Alla Vodka, Grilled Chicken Salad, Chicken Caesar Wrap, Prosciutto, Veggie Wrap, Blt, BBQ Chicken Salad, Caesar Salad, Bolognese, Panini, Neapolitan Pizza, Deli Sandwiches, Chicken Pesto Panini, Pizza, Chicken Salad, Chicken Wings, Fries, Carbonara, Grilled Chicken, Sicilian Pizza, Pasta Primavera, Pasta, Lasagna, Scrambled Eggs, Risotto, Calzone, French Fries, Sandwiches, Focaccia, Bacon, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Grilled Cheese, Bruschetta, Insalata Di Mare, Soup, Cannoli, Caprese, Salads, Greek Salad, Tortellini, Ravioli, Toast, Breakfast, Meatballs, Breakfast Sandwich, Antipasto Salad, Calamari, Buffalo Chicken Wrap, Fruit Salad, Cookies, Vegetarian Food, Coffee, and Italian Subs
What areas do you serve?
We serve the following areas: New Haven, Whitneyville, East Haven, East Rock, Prospect Hill, Wooster Square/Mill River, Spring Glen, West Haven, Downtown, Newhallville, Montowese, Fair Haven, Augerville, Dixwell, Hamden, Foxon, Beaver Hills, Long Wharf, Millbrook, Morris Cove.
